Former UPenn swimmer Lia Thomas is back in the headlines this week. Gaines considered Thomas accomplishments cheating. Our softball experts break down why Oklahoma is this good and who could end the OU dynasty in 2024, The Oklahoma dynasty: 53 straight wins, three titles in a row and zero sign of slowing down, OU softball joins list of NCAA title three-peaters, Cydney Sanders, Grace Lyons hit back-to-back HRs for Sooners, Jayda Coleman reaches over wall to make incredible HR robbery. Got laws getting passed allowing for flippin genital exams to play youth sports, like. The organization abandoned its 11-year-old, one-size-fits-all trans participation policy, in favor of a sport-by-sport model similar to what the International Olympic Committee adopted last November and plans to put in place next month. In the 200 and 500-yard freestyle competitions, she holds the fastest time in the nation. Former UPenn swimmer Lia Thomas is back in the headlines this week. So, depending on what FINA comes up with, and when, all this hand-wringing could be for nought. She will be just the second openly transgender woman to compete in the Olympics, after Laurel Hubbard of New Zealand, if she is selected for Team USA and participates in the Paris Olympics. Im sure being trans is challenging. (Ideally well pull ourselves out of this tailspin though.). Use of and/or registration on any portion of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement (updated 4/4/2023), Privacy Policy and Cookie Statement, and Your Privacy Choices and Rights (updated 7/1/2023). USA Swimming told Sports Illustrated that they would have "no issue" with Thomas taking on the trials and representing her country at the Olympics as long as she meets the criteria. The committee then deferred the decision to FINA, who voted 71.5 percent in favor of a policy requiring trans-athletes to have transitioned before the age of 12, by June 2022, as per Associated Press. June 19, 2023 09:30 PM. Transgender swimmer Lia Thomas was born in 1999 in Austin, Texas. She closed her Day 2 slate by swimming the second leg of Penn's 200 freestyle relay that placed fourth. That depends. It was sent by Nancy Hogshead-Makar, a 1984 Olympic swimming gold medalist, lawyer and chief executive of Champion Women, a womens sports advocacy organization. Note: This story has been updated to include a quote from USA Swimming clarifying that the organization updated its policy without having Nancy Hogshead-Makar serve as an adviser. From those nine finalists, one will be named as the Woman of the Year. (I think a lot of people just simply havent thought about it, much like they never really thought of a case like Lia Thomas. Thats another perspective.. *
Riley Gaines Spins Circles Around Harvard For Apparent Lia Thomas Jun 25, 2023 you support your own version of the world and whatever you approve. She was initially not permitted to participate. In most of lifes endeavors, it doesnt matter whether one is a man or a woman; competitive sports is a rare area where it does matter.
Trans swimmer Lia Thomas skips final regular-season meet as focus turns "Im not surprised its own by Disney," one fan added. Tuesday, and some say it could spell the end of Lia Thomass college swimming career.
Lia Thomas' teammates 'support her' but still want her barred from NCAA As, reported, USA Swimming states their elite policy applies only to members of USA Swimming and specific contests that are considered elite events. Lia Thomas, a transgender female competing on the University of Pennsylvania's women's swimming and diving team, prevailed in the 500-yard freestyle finals at the Ivy League Championships on Thursday, the first of several individual events that Thomas will be competing in over the course of the .
Lia Thomas' ex-teammate accuses UPenn of silencing swimmers - New York Post Like it or not, what she did and accomplished this year was groundbreaking. It was all true. USA Swimmings new policy divides student-athletes into two categories. And then I saw the locker room chart and saw that Lia definitely had a locker in the womens room, she said. The third phase, in which the NCAA will use the rules established by USA Swimming, will go into effect in the 2023-24 academic year. Being a woman has meant so many things throughout history many of them unenviable. I pretend to care because we cannot continue to pretend that this. I do have skin in this game, and its to create as inclusive a world as possible. (Puberty blockers plus hormone therapy leading to what is far more closely aligned with a cis puberty.). Scanlan, who described herself as religious, said she went to her Catholic leader to seek guidance on the situation. I think Lia being nominated makes sense, given that the nomination comes from UPenn and not some governing body looking at all ncaa athletes and their individual achievements, weighed with their contributions to the community. Ivy League meet against Harvard University in Cambridge, Mass., on January 22, 2022. Also, according to the organizations CEO, Tim Hinchey, Thomas is not a member of USA Swimming, as swimswam reported. I have, many times, said I am far from an expert on basically anything. She is also an Olympic silver medalist, having swam the heats of the 4200 free relay last year in Tokyo. Thank you @Riley_Gaines_ and Kylee Alons for standing up for female athletes. I support any trans person and their endeavors gladly but refuse to reduce womanhood to a feeling or a stereotype. Or, the out transgender student-athlete from the University of Pennsylvania may survive to swim again, in just two weeks at the NCAA Division I national championship meet. Two days later they had a formal meeting with us, with Lia excluded, and we were told you would regret talking to the media, she said.
Can Lia Thomas compete in the 2024 Paris Olympics? - Sportskeeda See the full list of swimmers and divers nominated for the 2022 NCAA Woman of the Year here: SwimSwam Magazines are big, coming in at nearly a pound per issue.
Lia Thomas Wins an NCAA Swimming Title - The New York Times A spokesperson for USA Swimming told me, Ms. one fan wrote. Lia Thomas is a role model for girls everywhere, Fact Check: Does Lia Thomas want to transition back to male?
The organization introduced a new decision-making panel comprised of three independent medical experts to guide eligibility decisions and.
Will Lia Thomas compete at the 2024 US Olympic Swimming Trials? This enabled her to compete on the women's team from 2021 to 2022 when she graduated. Lia Thomas won one event, but didn't break any records and her race times were not extraordinary. Lia Thomas, a transgender woman, warms up before swimming for the University of Pennsylvania at an [+] Ivy League meet against Harvard University in Cambridge, Mass., on January 22, 2022. All rights reserved. FINA agreed as such, following example of practically every individual who know anything at all about basic human endocrinology, biology, anatomy development, anything of sort. I was feeling like I cant feel hate and I dont feel hate towards Lia. Schools are allowed to nominate one graduating senior female student-athlete for the award, and up to two per school can be recognized if one of the student-athletes is either a person of color or an international student. But what will you do when another trans athlete comes along and wins even bigger titles? The University of Pennsylvania's Lia Thomas made history on Thursday as the first known transgender athlete to win an NCAA swimming championship when she took the title in the 500m freestyle.
Has Lia Thomas No Shame? | National Review My guess is that there arent any other National Champions whove made multiple national headlines competing for the Quakers this year. An ex-teammate of controversial transgender swimmer Lia Thomas has attacked UPenn for "shutting down" any criticism about the athlete joining the women's team in 2020 - and alleged that the. i def think i would. She set . If you really cared about the sport maybe wed be losing a lot less programs to Title IX than we have, where is that passion and outrage when schools across the country are forced to end their programs? I will continue to stand with you and we will save womens sports, Alabamas senior senator tweeted Thursday. *Im still not sure if this really is as a direct link as everyones been saying recently could just be the path of least resistance to overturning the rules that allowed Lia to compete (rules that were in place for more than a decade without anyone noticing) or it could be a naturalRead more .
Penn swimmers protest Lia Thomas' eligibility - Yahoo Sports We did not give our consent, they did not ask for our consent, but in that locker room we turned around and theres a 6-foot-4 biological man dropping his pants and watching us undress, and we were exposed to male genitalia, Riley Gaines told Fox News America Reports Wednesday. It appears that wasnt happening as fast as USA Swimming had hoped, and led to the new policy which the organization suggested may change again: This policy, effective immediately, said the press release, will remain in place until the release of an elite policy by FINA., There is certainly plenty of that to go around, on both sides. I cant escape into sports. Princeton's Ellie Marquardt, the 500 freestyle champion in 2020, finished third Thursday. Sure. Penn swimmer Lia Thomas approaches the starting block in the preliminary round of the 200-yard freestyle race at the NCAA women's swimming and diving championship inside Georgia Tech's McAuley Aquatic Center in Atlanta on Friday, March 18, 2022. I dont know what she has been through. On Tuesday, another group of Penn swimmers released a statement supporting Thomas after an unidentified Quakers swimmer spoke to Fox News about her, claiming she had a monumental advantage over her teammates after going through male puberty. Airline Accessibility Civil Rights Set To Advance As FAA Reauthorization Nears. After undergoing more than two years of hormone replacement therapy as part of her transition, she has posted the fastest times of any female college swimmer in two events this season. "Thank you for speaking out!!!" On Tuesday, USA Swimming issued a new policy that establishes eligibility criteria for transgender athletes in elite events. Penn senior Andie Myers, who competes in the freestyle and butterfly, wore a facemask with a transgender flag Thursday to show support for Thomas. The sentiments put forward by an anonymous member of our team are not representative of the feelings, values, and opinions of the entire Penn team, composed of 39 women with diverse backgrounds., Opinion: We need to be able to talk about trans athletes and womens sports. And, ideally, well get a ton more soon.). I know what all of the physical and mental stakes of being female are like. By.
Riley Gaines Spins Circles Around Harvard For Apparent Lia Thomas All rights reserved (About Us). If puberty is the main driver of athletic performance which I am granting for this argument, not saying its necessarily the case (because up until this year, rules were in placed not based on puberty, but managed levels of testosterone) then a trans man or trans woman, who does not undergo their puberty as assigned at birth, should have the same likelihood of achieving elite athletic performance as a cis man or cis woman. Previously, the International Olympic Committee was required to provide Hormone Replacement Therapy (HRT) to trans women for a year. I know personally what being a female athlete during a period where muscles were not seen as feminine was like. Youre not going to see that at the Olympics or at nationals. And then Lia came along. She described those who dont fully support her right to swim competitively in events designated for women as transphobic..
Lia Thomas Swimmer ranking before and after - Vim Buzz its gonna be interesting if well ever see it tho bc transitioning that early is illegal in many places and the factors coming together of being trans, transitioning that early and being a talented athlete, sticking with HRT and the sport until theyre like 20+ is gonna make that pool of people really really tiny or even 0 sometimes. (Photo by Hunter Martin/Getty Images). The terf talk is winning no supporters. Nobodys ever going to come and break womens records. The first one is found buried at the end of Tuesdays announcement. The former men's team swimmer, who joined the women's team after transitioning, sparked a lot of debate about transgender athletes this year. For me personally, the biggest thing was just when youre changing and theres all these people talking in the background you hear all these womens voices, and then all the sudden you hear a mans voice I would always kind of jump a little bit, Scanlan said. If your answer is based on FACTS: no; if your answer is based on feelings: maybe,Read more . When it became clear, all this new science was coming through, transgender advocates were saying: Oh, but its never going to happen. But before that, she must also be eligible according to World Aquatics guidelines for trans women. 'Her Rankings Have Bounced From #462 As A Male To #1 As A Female': 16 Lia Thomas Teammates Sign Letter Asking Penn Not To Sue NCAA, Bar Thomas From Competing | The Daily Wire News 'Her Rankings Have Bounced From #462 As A Male To #1 As A Female': 16 Lia Thomas Teammates Sign Letter Asking Penn Not To Sue NCAA, Bar Thomas From Competing The members of the womens team had been wronged. Rankings; Tickets; Lia Thomas: Didn't transition to gain advantage . You are so right, being a women is certainly much more than a feeling, an intention or the way someone dresses. By browsing this site, we may share your information with our social media partners in accordance with our, wrote a bill to block trans women from competing in womens collegiate athletics, former University of Kentucky swimmer Riley Gaines, Buy newspaper front pages, posters and more. Thomas won the 2022 NCAA Women of the Year Award. The swimmer also must show the concentration of testosterone in her blood has been less than 5 nanomoles per liter continuously for at least 36 months. I will continue to stand with you and we will save womens sports. Share.
Penn swimmer Lia Thomas is NCAA's first D-1 champion - Yahoo Sports The rating chart for current nominees is updated regularly. From a strictly UPenn point-of-view, there might be something to this. 26 Jun 2023 03:14:31 . Can Lia Thomas compete in the 2024 Paris Olympics. She is scheduled to swim the 200 freestyle and either the 1,650 or 100 freestyle later this week. I do have a problem with a woman who has gone through male puberty competing with cis women. . We want to love and we want to be there and I want to understand that, you know, someone is in pain. By Alan Blinder March 17, 2022 ATLANTA Lia Thomas, the transgender woman whose record-threatening times on the University of Pennsylvania's swim team made her a star of college athletics and. Trans women competing in womens sports does not threaten womens sports as a whole, Thomas has told ESPN. But while Osaka Inc. is thriving, Naomi, the woman, is hurting. After her undergraduate swimming career, University of Pennsylvania swimmer Thomas plans to compete for a spot at the 2024 Olympics. on January 22, 2022. Which outcome is more likely?
Brooke Forde, Lia Thomas Amongst Those Nominated For NCAA - SwimSwam We've received your submission.
Is Lia Thomas Finished? New USA Swimming Policy Means Big Changes - Forbes Alons told Rep. Greg Steube, R-Fla., she felt uncomfortable at the idea of Thomas being able to see her changing in the locker room during the 2022 championship that she changed in a closet, according to the congressman.
An ex-teammate of controversial transgender swimmer Lia Thomas has attacked UPenn for shutting down any criticism about the athlete joining the womens team in 2020 and alleged that the school effectively silenced them. Which outcome is more likely? Sen. Tommy Tuberville with Kylee Alons (l.) and Riley Gaines. Feb 10, 2022 More than 300 current and former NCAA, Team USA and international swimmers and divers signed on to an open letter sent to the NCAA on Thursday in support of Lia Thomas, an openly. A further stain on the history of post-pubescent female athleticsnot being part of the future means common sense prevails. As a male Lia placed about 7,106th. Yes, I would accept a transwoman who had not gone through male puberty competing fully and openly with cis women. As Webb outlined in her excellent report for, , this well-worn trope is a baseless myth. No swimmers were made available to media after the races.
Lia Thomas: 300-plus swimmers sign letter of support - Sports Illustrated 'Her Rankings Have Bounced From #462 As A Male - The Daily Wire Final MaxPreps Top 25 Baseball Rankings | 2023 Season; 2023 WIAA D1 State Championship: Hortonville vs.Whitefish Bay; Michigan commit Jack Counsell, son of Brewers manager, leads team to state title; Photo Galleries. And everything to do with the bigotry and rot that exists within the swimming community.
Thomas Frey Jun 15, 2023. Also among the newly minted conference champions Thursday was Yale's Iszac Henig, who won the 50 freestyle. Cookie Settings/Do Not Sell My Personal Information. The website claims to have made some bold statements about the same, but no major news outlet has reported on it at the time of writing. Ratings of judicial nominees are posted by Congressional session and are available for those nominated during the 101st Congress to the present. We were not forewarned beforehand that we would be sharing a locker room with Lia. Every sentence you write reeks of I am no racist but. 2023 Swim Swam Partners, LLC. Whataboutism and bringing up other subject not relevant here, pls keep away. This has nothing to do with swimming. Before altering its rules last month, the NCAA set a maximum of 10 nanomoles per liter for women's competition.
University of Pennsylvania swimmer Lia Thomas reacts after her team wins the 400 yard freestyle relay during the 2022 Ivy League Womens Swimming and Diving Championships at Blodgett Pool on. Im able to see first hand the impact the decisions we make in America have on the world. Your login session has expired. Probably, to some degree, both sides. In February 2022, the governing body said it would monitor testosterone levels to ensure they were below five nanomoles per liter for at least 36 months. Criticism of the performances has also come from people like three-time Olympic gold winner Nancy Hogshead-Makar. Thank you for your lovely addition to this conversation, turboturtle. Asked what her teammates were saying at the time, Scanlan said one athlete told her she thought Thomas record should have an asterisk and someone else suggested that the star should complete in exhibitions.
Lia Thomas the trans swimmer at the center of a media firestorm has Tuberville, the former football coach at Auburn who wrote a bill to block trans women from competing in womens collegiate athletics, tweeted a photo of himself posing with former University of Kentucky swimmer Riley Gaines and North Carolina States Kylee Alons.
Northern Highlands Lacrosse,
Articles L